WORKING AGE, REFERS TO THOSE MEMBERS OF THE POPULATION WHO ARE AGED BETWEEN 15-64. LINK
UNEMPLOYMENT REFERS TO PEOPLE OF ‘WORKING AGE’ WHO ARE ACTIVELY LOOKING FOR A JOB BUT WHO ARE UNABLE TO FIND WORK.
THE LABOUR FORCE REFERS TO THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE WHO ARE EMPLOYED + THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE OF WORKING AGE WHO ARE UNEMPLOYED BUT ACTIVELY SEEKING WORK.
UNDEREMPLOYMENT REFERS TO PEOPLE OF WORKING AGE WITH P/T JOBS WHEN THEY WOULD PREFER TO WORK F/T JOBS, WHO DO NOT MAKE FULL USE OF THEIR SKILLS & EDUCATION.
--With reference to the definitions above EXPLAIN why jobless people are not all considered to be unemployed, and why Zero-hour contract workers are not all considered to be underemployed--
"The technical definition of unemployment is...., therefore there are many people who are jobless, but who are not considered unemployed because...
The technical definition of underemployment is...., therefore a zero-hour contract worker may not be classified as underemployed if..."
POPULATION = 10,000
WORKING AGE POP = 9000
EMPLOYED POP = 6000
UNEMPLOYED POP = 2000
UNDEREMPLOYED POP = 500
LF = UNEMPLOYED POP + EMPLOYED POP
LF = (2000 + 6000) = 8000
THIS MEASURES THE % OF THE LABOUR FORCE WHICH ARE UNEMPLOYED.
POPULATION = 10,000
WORKING AGE POP = 9000
EMPLOYED POP = 6000
UNEMPLOYED POP = 2000
UNDEREMPLOYED POP = 500
UR = UNEMPLOYED POP / LABOUR FORCE
UR = 1000 / 8000 = 25%
THIS MEASURES THE % OF THE LABOUR FORCE WHO ARE UNDEREMPLOYED.
POPULATION = 10,000
WORKING AGE POP. = 9000
EMPLOYED = 6000
UNEMPLOYED = 2000
UNDEREMPLOYED POP. = 500
UR = UNDEREMPLOYED POP / LABOUR FORCE
UR = 500 / (8000) * 100 = 6.25%
THIS MEASURES THE % OF THE WORKING-AGE POPULATION WHO ARE PART OF THE LABOUR FORCE.
POPULATION = 10,000
WORKING AGE POP. = 9000
EMPLOYED = 6000
UNEMPLOYED = 2000
UNDEREMPLOYED = 500
PR = LABOUR FORCE / WORKING AGE POP.
8000 / 9000 = 88.8%
--TASK--
--UNDERESTIMATES JOBLESSNESS--
According to the strict definition of unemployment stated above, when workers are looking for work and are unable to find it, they are considered unemployed, however, if they FEEL DISCOURAGED and DECIDE TO GIVE UP due to LACK OF OPPORTUNITIES, they will not be considered unemployed anymore as they are not looking, even though they want to work. The same can be said for those who RETIRE EARLY out of FRUSTRATION. Both these groups will not show up in official unemployment statistics despite wanting to work.
According to the strict definition of unemployment stated above, when workers aren't looking for work then they aren't considered unemployed, yet at any one time, there are always a large number of people who have TEMPORARILY STOPPED WORKING & LOOKING FOR WORK in order to RETRAIN their skills, presumably because they can't get hired with their current skill sets.
In this situation, if these people decided not to retrain then they would be classed as structurally unemployed, yet because they decide to retrain, they are not classified as unemployed, yet they are still jobless, so the unemployment rate is lower that it should be.
Unemployment statistics DO NOT DETAIL THE HOURS WORKED by the employed, as such they also include those workers who want to work more hours but can't ('THE UNDEREMPLOYED').
In the worst-case scenario some workers are on 'ZERO-HOURS' contracts, which make them technically employed, however, their contracts do not stipulate a fixed amount of hours and can vary form many to zero.
Because these people are included in the 'EMPLOYED POPULATION' the unemployment rate gives a misleadingly low rate.
Unemployment statistics DO NOT DETAIL WHETHER WORKERS ARE DOING JOBS WHICH ALIGN WITH THEIR SKILLSETS, as such they also include those workers who are working in jobs that do not utilise their training and expertise, making them 'UNDEREMPLOYED'. E.g Mr.B working in KFC.
Whilst not being technically unemployed nor underemployed in terms of hours, these people can be seen as a "PRODUCTIVITY LOSS" and signal that the economy is not developing as it should.
YES! If members of the unemployed population LEAVE the LABOUR FORCE (Participation rate falls).
YES! If members of the unemployed population become employed, however, what if the hours they work barely change? Are they still mostly jobless and still unemployed?
--OVERESTIMATES JOBLESSNESS--
Unemployment figures do not include people working in the underground economy (or informal economy). This is the portion of the economy that is unregistered, legally unregulated and not reported to tax authorities. Some people may be officially registered as unemployed, yet they may be working in an unreported (underground) activity.
https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/rankings/shadow_economy/
https://pdfhost.io/v/7n05MJ79b_wp1817 (Size of informal sector)
YES! If members of the unemployed population increase (Participation rate rises), and they are also working in the informal sector.
--IGNORES POPULATION GROUPS--
REGION – regions with declining industries may have higher unemployment rates than other regions.
GENDER – women sometimes face higher unemployment rates than men.
ETHNICITY – some ethnic groups may be disadvantaged due to discrimination, or due to lower levels of education and training.
AGE – youth unemployment (usually referring to persons under the age of 25) often face higher unemployment rates than older population groups, often due to lower skill levels; people who are aging also sometimes face higher unemployment rates as employers may be less willing to employ them
EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT – people who are relatively less skilled may have higher unemployment rates than more skilled workers (though in some countries higher unemployment rates may be found among highly educated groups).
Firstly, find the CURRENT UNEMPLOYMENT RATE IN SINGAPORE/YOUR HOME COUNTRY (LINK HERE) as your RWE, then, using the information above, write an answer to the question below:
--Does the unemployment rate provide a realistic gauge of the level of 'joblessness' in a country?--
In your answer be sure to include why it might UNDERESTIMATE or OVERESTIMATE the true level as well as how it may not be representative of the 'AVERAGE SINGAPOREAN'.
"The unemployment rate is defined as...."
"....it can be calculated as follows...."
"The official unemployment rate in Singapore is currently...."
"As to why this unemployment rate might not be a realistic gauge of the level of joblessness in a country, we need to consider factors that cause it to overestimate and underestimate it....."
"In terms of overestimating the problem, factors such as....."
"In terms of underestimating the problem, factors such as....."
GOOGLE SEARCH TIP: TRY TYPING "UNEMPLOYMENT RATE MISLEADING'
CNBC: HERE'S WHY THE JOBLESS CLAIMS ARE THE WRONG WAY TO UNDERSTAND UNEMPLOYMENT IN THE US
ABC: WHAT ARE MILLIONS OF UNEMPLOYED PEOPLE EXCLUDED FROM OUR MONTHLY 'UNEMPLOYMENT' DATA?
POLITICO: UNEMPLOYMENT IS MUCH WORSE THAN YOU THINK--HERE'S WHY.
INSIDER: MISLEADING UNEMPLOYMENT DATA MAY BE PROMPTING THE FED AND THE BOE TO MAKE A HUGE ERROR.
SAVINGS.COM: 'HIGHLY MISLEADING' UNEMPLOYMENT RATE DROPS TO 4.5%.
QUARTZ: IF THE US UNEMPLOYMENT RATE INCLUDED EVERYONE WHO SAYS THEY WANT A JOB, IT WOULD BE DOUBLE.
POLITICO: ''TRUE UNEMPLOYMENT' IS A LOT HIGHER THAN YOU THINK.
SMART ASSET: TOP 5 PROBLEMS WITH THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE
BROOKINGS: WHAT DOS THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE MEASURE?
The SUPPLY OF LABOUR CURVE is determined by those willing and able to supply their labour at each average real wage rate. Clearly, to be willing and able to supply your labour, you MUST possess not only the skills (ability) currently being demanded but also the willingness to take the positions on offer
The DEMAND FOR LABOUR is determined by those firms willing and able to demand those workers who have the required skillsets and who will accept the job offers at each average real wage rate.
At EQUILIBRIUM IN THE LABOUR MARKET, we get the average real wage accepted by those employed members of the labour force.
As mentioned the labour force is made up both the EMPLOYED & THE UNEMPLOYED members of the labour force hence at each real wage level the labour force will be greater than the employed population, so we draw the labour force curve to the RIGHT of the S of L curve.
Given that these employed members account for the labour input into national output (Real GDP), we can conclude that THE EQUILIBRIUM LEVEL OF EMPLOYMENT IN THE LABOUR MARKET (THE EMPLOYED POP.) corresponds to THE FULL EMPLOYMENT LEVEL of REAL GDP while the UNEMPLOYED POP. corresponds to THE NATURAL RATE OF UNEMPLOYMENT (NRU).
So far we know that there is a level of unemployment that exists at 'FULL EMPLOYMENT' called the 'NATURAL RATE OF UNEMPLOYMENT (NRU)', which is in fact the sum of THREE distinct types of unemployment.
NRU = STRUCTURAL + SEASONAL + FRICTIONAL
STRUCTURAL UNEMPLOYMENT occurs as a result of...
1) CHANGE IN DEMAND for PARTICULAR TYPE of LABOUR SKILLS,
Due to GEOGRAPHICAL CHANGES, in the location of an entire industry, those who are unable to move will become structurally unemployed.
Due to TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGES, some jobs become OBSOLETE, and all demand disappears. E.g, ATMs have replaced bank tellers
Due to STRUCTURAL CHANGES, which occur when an economy develops, often primary sector jobs will disappear and be replaced by secondary and tertiary jobs.
2) LABOUR MARKET RIGIDITIES are factors preventing the forces of supply and demand from operating in the labour market. They include:
MINIMUM WAGE LEGISLATION, which, if set above equilibrium leads to a surplus of labour (aka unemployed people).
LABOUR UNION ACTIVITIES and wage bargaining with employers, resulting in higher than equilibrium wages also causing unemployment
EMPLOYMENT PROTECTION LAWS, which make it costly for firms to fire workers (because they must pay compensation), thus making firms more cautious about hiring
GENEROUS UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS, which increase the attractiveness of remaining unemployed and reduce the incentives to work.
--IS IT SERIOUS?--
YES!!! Because...
It’s usually LONG-TERM and even PERMANENT.
Involves a lack of demand for SPECIFIC SKILLS rather than a lack of general demand due to a recession, hence expansionary demand-side policies are useless, and the problem will not improve cyclical.
SKILLSETS cannot be transferred to SUNRISE industries as often the industry that declines (SUNSET) is in the PRIMARY or SECONDARY sector e.g. Can a fisherman become a programmer?
Requires COSTLY GOV'T INTERVENTION, e.g. unemployment benefits
Note: In the case of structural unemployment, we assume that the wage rate does not fall immediately and the market creates excess supply of labour at the original wage after the demand falls. If the market adjusted immediately, then there would be no structurally unemployed as by definiton, the market has no excess supply (no one is looking to work and cant find work)
FRICTIONAL UNEMPLOYMENT refers to those unemployed workers who are 'BETWEEN JOBS', which means they are in the process of looking for work for the first time, or looking for a new job.
It is a ‘naturally occurring’ type of unemployment that is unavoidable and is not considered serious because…
It’s usually TEMPORARY*.
Does not involve lack of demand for skills.
Inevitable in GROWING economy. e.g. Moving between sunrise industries
Can be solved relatively easily compared to structural.
Caused mainly by incomplete information.
*Though it could turn structural if the person waits too long.
As the name suggests, this type of unemployment occurs due to the fact that demand for this type of worker is seasonal, and therefore in the 'OFF-SEASON', these worker are unemployed. Seasonal unemployment can be reduced by RETRAINING and UPSKILLING into ALL-SEASON careers. It is a ‘naturally occurring’ type of unemployment that is unavoidable.
When an economy enters a RECESSION, AD falls, and unemployment rises. When unemployment is caused by falling AD it is referred to as CYCLICAL UNEMPLOYMENT, on account of the fact that it occurs during cyclical fluctuations in the business cycle.
Being unemployed and unable to secure a job involves a loss of income, increased indebtedness as people must borrow to survive, as well as a LOSS OF SELF-ESTEEM. All these factors cause great PSYCHOLOGICAL STRESS, sometimes resulting in LOWER LEVELS OF HEALTH, FAMILY BREAKDOWN, and even SUICIDE.
Greater social problems. High rates of unemployment, particularly when they are unequally distributed for the reasons noted earlier, can lead to serious social problems, including INCREASED CRIME and VIOLENCE, DRUG USE, and HOMELESSNESS.
A LOSS OF REAL GDP. Since fewer people work than are available to work, the amount of output produced is less than the level the economy is capable of producing.
A LOSS OF INCOME FOR UNEMPLOYED WORKERS. People who are unemployed will have reduced earnings.
A LOSS OF TAX REVENUE FOR THE GOV'T. Since unemployed people do not have income from work, they do not pay income taxes; this results in less tax revenue for the government.
COST TO THE GOV'T OF UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS. If the government pays unemployment benefits to unemployed workers, the less tax revenue left over to pay for important government-provided goods and services such as public goods and merit goods.
GOV'T COST OF DEALING WITH SOCIAL PROBLEMS. In addition, to unemployment benefits, the increased crime and social disorder that unemployment creates will inevitably lead to higher government expenditure on crime prevention, which again diverts funds away from public and merit goods.
MORE UNEQUAL DISTRIBUTION OF INCOME. Clearly, the loss of income for the unemployed will make the income gap wider, the effects of increasing income inequalities and resulting poverty tend to be concentrated among population groups who are more disadvantaged to begin with. If unemployment is high or tends to persist over long periods of time, this may lead to increased social tensions and social unrest.
THE CYCLICALLY UNEMPLOYED MAY BECOME LONG-TERM STRUCTURALLY UNEMPLOYED because if they are out of work for too long, their abilities and skills may become rusty, even worse these skills may become obsolete whilst firms find ways to manage with fewer workers through automation.
-EXPLAIN THE CAUSE OF CYCLICAL (DEMAND-DEFICIENT) UNEMPLOYMENT. 10 MODEL
-EXPLAIN WHY STRUCTURAL UNEMPLOYMENT MIGHT OCCUR IN AN ECONOMY.10
-EVALUATE GOVERNMENT POLICIES TO DEAL WITH THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF UNEMPLOYMENT.15
-EXPLAIN THE DIFFICULTIES INVOLVED IN MEASURING THE LEVEL OF UNEMPLOYMENT. 10
-EXPLAIN WHAT IS MEANT BY the NATURAL RATE OF UNEMPLOYMENT. 10
-TO WHAT EXTENT MIGHT UNEMPLOYMENT REPRESENT AN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL PROBLEM? 15
Distinguish between structural and demand-deficient (cyclical) unemployment.
Explain why structural unemployment may occur in an economy.
Explain the following different types of unemployment: Frictional unemployment; Structural unemployment; Cyclical/ demand-deficient/ Keynesian unemployment
There are various types of unemployment. Explain how any three types of unemployment may cause a rise in the unemployment rate of an economy.
Explain the difference between cyclical / demand-deficient and structural unemployment.
Explain why a country may wish to reduce its unemployment rate.
Explain why structural unemployment may occur in an economy.
Explain the cause of cyclical (demand-deficient) unemployment.
Explain why structural unemployment might occur in an economy.
Explain the difficulties involved in measuring the level of unemployment.
Explain what is meant by natural rate of unemployment.
Explain two ways a government can reduce its natural rate of unemployment.
Use the Phillips Curve to explain the concept of the natural rate of unemployment.
‘Unemployment remains persistently high in a majority of countries throughout the world.’ Explain the economic problems that high unemployment may cause for a country.
Explain the consequences of unemployment in an economy.
Explain the social costs of unemployment? In view of these costs, explain why some countries give higher priority to tackling other problems such as inflation.
Unemployment can either be structural or cyclical. Explain how government intervention would differ in each case.