ECONOMIC INTEGRATION refers to ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION BETWEEN COUNTRIES and CO-ORDINATION of THEIR ECONOMIC POLICES, leading to increased economic links between them.
There are VARIOUS DEGREES OF INTEGRATION, depending on the type of agreement made between the co-operating countries, and the degree to which barriers between them are removed.
A PREFERENTIAL TRADE AGREEMENT (PTA) is an agreement between 2+ countries to lower trade barriers between each other on PARTICULAR PRODUCTS.
A BILATERAL TRADE AGREEMENT is an agreement between TWO COUNTRIES.
A MULTILATERAL TRADE AGREEMENT involves an agreement between MANY COUNTRIES.
A REGIONAL TRADE AGREEMENT is an agreement between a group of countries that are WITHIN A GEOGRAPHICAL REGION.
--TYPES OF TRADING BLOC--
A FREE-TRADE AREA (FTA) refers to a group of countries that AGREE TO ELIMINATE TRADE BARRIERS between themselves. Each member country RETAINS THE RIGHT TO PURSUE ITS OWN TRADE POLICY TOWARDS NON-MEMBERS.
--EXAMPLES of FTAs--
WHY IS THIS PROBLEMATIC? One problem that arises in free trade areas is that a product may be imported into the FTA by the country that has the lowest external trade barriers, and then sold to countries within the FTA that have higher external trade barriers.
For example, the Uk may have a 10% tariff on Chinese imports while France has a 2% tariff, so France could import from China then export to the UK, under the guise of 'Made in France'
This problem arises because each country has its own individual barriers toward non-members. It creates difficulties for those countries with higher barriers because they may end up importing more of the good than they would like. To deal with this problem, FTAs make complicated ‘rules of origin’ for imports, designed to prevent goods from entering countries with lower external barriers.
A CUSTOMS UNION consists of a group of countries that FULFILS THE REQUIREMENTS OF AN FTA but in addition ADOPTS A COMMON TARIFF POLICY TOWARDS NON-MEMBER COUNTRIES. This tariff is termed a 'COMMON EXTERNAL TARIFF' (CET).
Therefore each country in a customs union is NO LONGER FREE TO DETERMINE ITS OWN TRADE POLICY TOWARDS NON-MEMBERS but must adopt the policy agreed upon by the customs union.
Also, the MEMBER COUNTRIES ACT AS A SINGLE GROUP IN TRADE NEGOTIATIONS rather than individual countries with NON-MEMBERS, EG: EU vs China
A COMMON MARKET has all the characteristics of a CUSTOMS UNION in terms of NO TRADE BARRIERS, but in addition, it also ELIMINATES BARRIERS to the MOVEMENT OF FACTORS OF PRODUCTION, in particular, LABOUR and CAPITAL resources.
LABOUR and CAPITAL are FREE TO CROSS ALL BORDERS and move, travel and find employment freely within all member countries.
The best-known common market is the European Economic Community (EEC, the precursor of the present European Union), formed in 1957.
Another example is the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) Single Market and Economy (CSME).
TRADE CREATION refers to a situation where HIGHER-COST PRODUCTS THAT A COUNTRY USED TO IMPORT or PRODUCE DOMESTICALLY BEFORE MEMBERSHIP are now REPLACED BY CHEAPER IMPORTS AFTER MEMBERSHIP. This is similar to the idea of a ‘TARIFF-REMOVAL’, except it has come about due to the joining of a customs union with this low-cost importer.
For the IMPORTER they will RECEIVE ECONOMIES OF SCALE as well as EARN EXPORT REVENUE that will HELP ECONOMIC GROWTH while DOMESTIC FIRMS WILL FACE STIFFER COMPETITION and will HAVE TO IMPROVE EFFICIENCY TO SURVIVE, in the long run, COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGES should be IMPROVED and more ALLOCATIVE EFFICIENCY created.
We can see below that when the UK joins the EU it is able to import the good at a cheaper price, as it no longer has to pay the EU's CET of 50%.
The removal of trade barriers results in increased competition among producers in member countries. With low or no barriers, IMPORTS INCREASE, forcing domestic producers to compete with lower-cost producers from other countries. This FORCES-OUT INEFFICIENT HIGHER-COST DOMESTIC PRODUCERS leading to LOWER PRICES FOR CONSUMERS and an IMPROVED ALLOCATION OF RESOURCES.
This is an obvious benefit arising from the ABILITY OF FIRMS TO SELL BEYOND THEIR NATIONAL BOUNDARIES, increasing their exports and leading to GREATER REVENUES.
ECONOMIC INTEGRATION allows member countries to GAIN FROM ECONOMIES OF SCALE. When an economy opens itself up to free trade with other countries, its EXPORTS ARE LIKELY TO INCREASE (assuming it is a relatively efficient producer), and AS THE SIZE OF THE MARKET EXPANDS, THE FIRM CAN ACHIEVE LOWER AVERAGE COSTS OF PRODUCTION which can lead to LOWER PRICES and GREATER EXPORT COMPETITIVENESS.
The elimination of trade barriers (along with INCREASED COMPETITION and ECONOMIES OF SCALE) increased competition and economies of scale) results in LOWER PRICES FOR CONSUMERS. In addition, increased imports mean a GREATER VARIETY OF GOODS from which consumers can choose.
ENLARGED MARKETS ATTRACT INCREASED INVESTMENTS by both DOMESTIC and FOREIGN firms (MNCs) that want to TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THE LARGER MARKET SIZE.
A MAJOR INCENTIVE FOR FIRMS OUTSIDE THE BLOC TO INVEST WITHIN THE BLOC is the AVOIDANCE of any TARIFF (and/or all other forms of protectionism imposed on non-members)
If a trading bloc develops into a COMMON MARKET, which involves FREE MOVEMENT OF FACTORS OF PRODUCTION, this also results in BETTER USE OF THESE WITHIN THE BLOC.
For example, WHEN A LABOUR SHORTAGE OCCURS IN ONE MEMBER COUNTRY while a SURPLUS OCCURS IN ANOTHER, workers are MORE ABLE to MOVE ACROSS BORDERS to FILL THE VACANCIES.
The elimination of trade barriers, leading to a better utilisation of resources and improved efficiency in production, allows for more rapid economic growth,
GREATER ECONOMIC INTEGRATION is likely to result in a REDUCED LIKELIHOOD OF HOSTILITIES BETWEEN COUNTRIES whose economies become MORE INTERDEPENDENT through increased trade, investment, labour, and financial flows.
Imagine you are a small, independent store becoming part of the Amazon online family which gives you access to all types of cost saving services as well as massive online exposure on its marketplace at a lower member rate.
As a member, however you now have to charge all non-members a higher rate.
Using the list of advantages above create an analogy illustrating how each of these benefits can be enjoyed by the new online store.
--DISADVANTAGES OF TRADING BLOCS--
TRADE DIVERSION refers to a situation where LOWER-COST PRODUCTS THAT A COUNTRY USED TO IMPORT BEFORE MEMBERSHIP are now REPLACED BY HIGHER PRICED IMPORTS AFTER MEMBERSHIP.
This PROBLEM occurs when the LOW-COST importer DOES NOT JOIN THE TRADING BLOC and is THEREFORE LIABLE FOR THE NON-MEMBER TARIFF, as such TRADE IS NOW 'DIVERTED', AWAY FROM THIS LOW-COST IMPORTER TOWARDS A LESS-EFFICIENT & HIGHER COST MEMBER.
We can see below, that when the UK is not a member of the EU it pays $6 per unit for its imports from the US (The low-cost producer), however, after it joins the EU (And the US doesn't join) its cheapest source for this particular import becomes $8 from one of the less-efficient EU members.
As mentioned the potential for LOW-COST & MORE-EFFICIENT IMPORTERS to enter the market and force out UNCOMPETITIVE DOMESTIC FIRMS, raises the possibility of INCREASED DOMESTIC UNEMPLOYMENT.
The break-up of the world trading system into many blocs can create trade conflicts between different blocs that may slow down the process of global trade liberalisation. Trading blocs may enjoy free trade and all its benefits within the bloc, but trade barriers on non-members may result in limiting rather than increasing trade on a global scale. This would lead to a worse global allocation of resources, lower global output, a weakened role for the WTO, and a risk of breaking up the global economy into many regional trading blocs.
Countries forming a trading bloc are UNLIKELY TO GAIN EQUALLY from the operation of the trading bloc, and this CREATES THE POTENTIAL FOR CONFLICTS BETWEEN MEMBERS and makes it DIFFICULT TO REACH AGREEMENTS.
SOVEREIGNTY refers to AUTHORITY OVER DECISION-MAKING WITHIN THE NATIONAL ECONOMY. The formation of trading blocs involves GIVING UP SOME OF THIS AUTHORITY to an external authority.
Continuing on from our online store analogy do the following:
Using the list of disadvantages above expand the previous analogy illustrating how each of these can be suffered by the new online store.
Given what you have read above, can you
CREATE A PAPER 2 DATA RESPONSE QUESTION THAT FEATIRES AS MANY OF THESE DISADVATAGES AND ADVANTAGES AS POSSIBEL
HYPOTHETICAL COUNTRY IS FINE...
COMMON MKT
--MONETARY UNION--
MONETARY UNION involves a far greater degree of integration than a common market, and occurs when the member countries of a common market adopt a common currency and a common central bank responsible for monetary policy.
--ADVANTAGES OF MONETARY UNION--
Exchange rate fluctuations create risks and uncertainties for traders and investors, who do not know what the future exchange rates will be. A SINGLE CURRENCY ELIMINATES THE RISKS AND UNCERTAINTIES, with benefits for importers and exporters, consumers, and investors, thereby encouraging trade and investments across boundaries. This contributes to achieving a more efficient allocation of resources.
ELIMINATES TRANSACTION COSTS: Whenever there is a conversion of one currency into another, banks (or others) charge a fee for the conversion; this is a type of transaction cost. A single currency eliminates these transaction costs, resulting in significant savings that have the effect of encouraging trade, investments and international financial flows of all kinds. It has been estimated that the savings from the elimination of transaction costs of currency conversions within the eurozone countries amount to about 1% of the combined GDPs of the countries involved.
PRICE TRANSPARENCY refers to the ability of consumers and firms to compare prices in all the countries that have adopted a common currency without having to make exchange-rate calculations and conversions. This makes it easier for all economic decision-makers to see price differences quickly and accurately across countries, and has the effect of promoting competition and efficiency.
PROMOTES A HIGHER LEVEL OF INWARD INVESTMENT: Inward investment refers to investments from outsiders towards the member countries with a common currency, and these can be expected to rise because of the absence of currency risk within an expanded market, resulting in greater economic growth.
LOW RATES OF INFLATION => LOW-INTEREST RATES => MORE INVESTMENT: A single currency under the control of a single central bank (such as the European Central Bank) committed to maintaining price stability results in low rates of inflation, leading to several benefits: low rates of interest, higher levels of investment, and higher levels of output.
--DISADVANTAGES OF MONETARY UNION--
A single currency involves a LOSS OF EXCHANGE RATES AS A MECHANISM FOR ADJUSTMENTS. If a member country has a trade deficit with another member country, it NO LONGER HAS ITS OWN NATIONAL CURRENCY TO DEPRECIATE (or DEVALUE in a fixed system) to correct the imbalance BY MAKING ITS EXPORTS CHEAPER.
Similarly, if a member country has a HIGHER RATE OF INFLATION and its goods become less competitive abroad, the problem cannot be solved by currency depreciation or devaluation, TO LOWER IMPORTED INFLATION.
One of the greatest threats to MONETARY UNION is for a member to exit due to its need to use CONTRACTIONARY MONETARY POLICY to COMBAT INFLATION or EXPANSIONARY MONETARY POLICY to combat a RECESSION.
Therefore it is VITAL that members are FIXATED on GOOD-DEMAND-SIDE MANAGEMENT meaning PRICE STABILITY is essential. Therefore rather than have individual governments use interest rates
expansionary/contractionary monetary policies to combat recessions or high inflation. This leaves only fiscal policies in your own hand. With this in mind, all countries that join this type of union MUST agree to a number of conditions known as ‘convergence requirements’, including limiting their rate of inflation, limiting their budget deficit to 3% of GDP, and limiting their government debt to 60% of GDP.
From this perspective, some of the advantages and
disadvantages of monetary union are similar to the
advantages and disadvantages of fi xed versus fl exible
exchange rates (see page 402). In addition, monetary
union has a further very signifi cant characteristic: the
creation of a single currency, overseen and controlled
by a single central bank. This characteristic offers
further potential benefi ts, as well as possible costs.
A single currency involves loss of monetary policy as an instrument of economic policy. For all eurozone countries, monetary policy is the responsibility of the European Central Bank, the objective being price stability for the region as a whole. Each individual country, whatever its particular circumstances (higher or lower inflation, unemployment, etc., than the average of the eurozone countries), is unable to carry out its own monetary policy to influence the rate of interest and hence the level of economic activity within its boundaries.
Fiscal policy is constrained by the convergence requirements. Whereas each member country retains the ability to carry out its own fiscal policy, there are restrictions imposed by the convergence requirements, as noted above: in the case of European Monetary Union, total public debt cannot be greater than 60% of GDP and the budget deficit of any given year cannot be greater than 3% of GDP.
This limits the government’s ability to borrow according to domestic needs and priorities. For example, in a recession, since a government cannot pursue an independent expansionary monetary policy, it would need to pursue expansionary fiscal policy; however, if its deficit or debt is already approaching the limits, it cannot do this without violating the rules.
Monetary policy pursued by the single central bank impacts differently on each member country, depending on its own particular circumstances. Since countries are likely to differ from each other with respect to degrees of inflation, unemployment, etc., or generally where they are in the business cycle, the single monetary policy pursued by the single central bank is unlikely to suit every country’s needs and may be inappropriate. For example, if some countries face unemployment and others face inflation, an expansionary monetary policy would suit the needs of the first group but would make the inflation worse in the second group.
Monetary policy pursued by the single central bank impacts differently on each member country, depending on its own particular circumstances. Since countries are likely to differ from each other with respect to degrees of inflation, unemployment, etc., or generally where they are in the business cycle, the single monetary policy pursued by the single central bank is unlikely to suit every country’s needs and may be inappropriate. For example, if some countries face unemployment and others face inflation, an expansionary monetary policy would suit the needs of the first group but would make the inflation worse in the second group.
--WORLD TRADE ORGANISATION--
1) NON-DISCRIMINATION: The WTO continues the GATT’s emphasis on equal, non-discriminatory treatment for all member countries (excepting trading blocs).
2) FREE TRADE: Trade barriers should be lowered through negotiations.
3) PREDICTABILITY: Governments, firms, investors, etc., should have confidence that trade barriers will not be raised arbitrarily.
4) PROMOTION OF FAIR COMPETITION: Unfair practices such as dumping and export subsidies are discouraged.
5) DEVELOPMENT & ECONOMIC REFORM SHOULD BE ENCOURAGED Developing countries should be offered flexibility with respect to lowering their trade barriers, more time to adjust to change and special privileges.
• IT ADMINISTERS WTO TRDE AGREEMENTS: The WTO helps in the implementation and administration of international trade agreements.
• IT PROVIDES A FORUM FOR TRADE NEGOTIATIONS: The WTO provides a forum for members to discuss their trade problems and negotiate trade agreements on how to liberalise trade. This is one of the most important WTO functions.
• IT HANDLES TRADE DISPUTES: When WTO members disagree on trade issues, the WTO makes decisions to resolve the differences on the basis of the legal foundations of the trade agreements. CHECK IT OUT HERE!
• IT MONITORS NATIONAL TRADE POLICIES: The WTO carries out periodic reviews of its members’ national trade policies. Members are required to notify the WTO of any changes in trade policy. The WTO also examines new trading bloc arrangements.
• IT PROVIDES TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE & TRAINING FOR DEVELOPING COUNTRIES: The assistance provided to developing countries concerns trade-related issues arising from WTO trade agreements.
• IT FACILITATES CO-OPERATION WITH OTHER INT'L ORGANISATIONS: The WTO cooperates with other international organisations (such as the World Bank and International Monetary Fund discussed in Chapter 18), in order to facilitate co-ordination of global polices.
--CRITICISMS--
1) DEVELOPED COUNTRIES received GREATER TARIFF REDUCTIONS than developing ones.
2) The use of NON-TARIFF METHODS by developed nations against the exports of developing countries not addressed. eg. red tape etc...
3) PROTECTION of INTELLECTUAL RIGHTS, meant the cost of developing nations obtaining new technology remained prohibitively high.
4) MNCs WERE NO LONGER REQUIRED TO BUY THEIR SUPPLIES LOCALLY and so local firms and workers gained little from these trade operations.
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION & EXPORT SUBSIDIES GIVEN TO FARMERS IN DEVELOPED NATIONS has NOT BEEN DEALT WITH, nor has the issue of them DUMPING SURPLUSES ON THE WORLD MARKETS, and subsequently lowering the world price, to the detriment of developing countries who overwhelmingly rely on agricultural exports.
The WTO TREATS ALL COUNTRIES AS IF THEY ARE AT THE SAME LEVEL OF DEVELOPMENT, except for LDCs. Therefore they EXPECT ALL DEVELOPING NATIONS TO FOLLOW THE SAME TRADE LIBERALISATION MEASURES AS DEVELOPED NATIONS, which disadvantages the former, who may still need protection for their infant industries.
The WTO HAS ENCOURAGED THE REMOVAL OF TRADE BARRIERS ON GOODS the removal of trade barriers on goods that have very LOW ENVIRONMENTAL STANDARDS, have questionable records on their USE OF CHILD LABOUR and which can be considered DEMERIT GOODS (overproduced due to government support).
Critics argue that the WTO is actually UNDEMOCRATIC, and DECISIONS ARE BASED ON THE POWER OF MEMBERS in spite of the one vote per member rule. The economically more POWERFUL COUNTRIES CAN USE THE THREAT OF RETALIATION, to force the vote of weaker nations in their favour.
--CHALLENGES--
Despite membership of the WTO, many MEMBERS HAVE SOUGHT TO MAKE 'PLURILATERAL TRADE AGREEMENTS' between themselves, which are voluntary in nature and are not multilateral in line with the WTO objectives, hence HAMPERING TRADE LIBERALISATION.
One of the most important roles of the WTO is its ability to resolve trade disputes between members. This is carried out by a revolving committee of 7 judges known as the 'Appellate Body', however Since the end of 2018, the US has blocked new appointments, hence this is no longer possible.
--KEY CONCEPT--
Increasing levels of economic integration between nations highlight interdependence between the economies of different countries. Increasing levels of international trade within the different types of trading blocs show one level of interdependence, but the emergence of common markets and monetary union demonstrates an even deeper level of transnational cooperation. The European Union probably represents the most advanced level of international interdependence. Closer and closer trading ties, the free movement of labour and capital, a common currency (Euro) and a central bank make the EU a model of interdependence between nations. The closer and closer ties between countries in the EU are not without its challenges and the UK's 'Brexit' from the EU showed a clash between international cooperation and loss of national sovereignty.
Distinguish between a free trade area (such as ASEAN), a customs union and a common market. (4)
Using information from the text/data and your knowledge of economics, evaluate the possible effects of this agreement on trade between India and Malaysia.
Using information from the text/data and your knowledge of economics, evaluate the possible impact of Latvia joining the eurozone.
Using information from the text/data and your knowledge of economics, discuss the possible advantages and disadvantages of a monetary union for members of the West African Monetary Zone (WAMZ).
Evaluate the likely impact on South Sudan of its membership of the EAC common market
Explain possible disadvantages that may be associated with the adoption of a single currency.
Explain the differences between free trade areas (FTAs), customs unions and common markets as types of international economic integration.
Using real world examples, explain the factors that allow a country to have a comparative advantage in the production of a good or service.
With the aid of a diagram, explain the potential trade gains and trade losses arising from the formation customs union.
Evaluate the likely impact on South Sudan of its membership of the EAC common market
Define the term monetary union indicated in bold in the text (2)
Define the term comparative advantage indicated in bold in the text (2)
Evaluate the likely impact on South Sudan of its membership of the EAC common market. (8)