The benefits of a motivated Mr. B to TES
INCREASED PRODUCTIVITY:
"I love teaching IGCSE Business Studies and want to get as many of my students A* as possible!"
REDUCED ABSENTEEISM:
"I really love teaching IGCSE Business Studies, I never want to miss a a day of work!"
REDUCED LABOUR TURNOVER:
"I love teaching IGCSE Business Studies at TES so much and I never want to leave!"
Copy the three 'Benefits of a motivated Mr. B to TES', into your digital doc and REPHRASE to create you own 'Benefits of a motivated student to TES'.
"A motivated student leads to increased productivity in terms of....."
"A motivated student leads to reduced student absenteeism, because..."
"A motivated student leads to reduced student turnover, due to..."
--"MONEY IS THE ONLY MOTIVATOR"--
F. W. TAYLOR assumed all workers were motivated by personal gain and isolated MONEY as the key motivating factor.
His work was based on observations made in Steel factories in which he broke down jobs into simpler processes so that workers only had to focus on simple repetitive actions ('DIVISION OF LABOUR'), which Taylor would then time and calculate the optimum expected repetitions per hour.
This way the WORKERS WOULD BECOME MORE AND MORE SPECIALISED and as a result PRODUCTIVITY would RISE, for which workers would RECEIVE MONETRAY REWARDS.
--LIMITATIONS--
In reality, MONEY IS NOT THE ONLY MOTIVATOR and workers are motivated by numerous non-financial factors such as a clean and comfortable working environment, and praise etc.
Ask yourself why do footballers who get higher salaries still underperform?
Furthermore, Taylor's method was ONLY REALLY APPLICABLE TO SITUATIONS WHERE INDIVIDUAL EFFORT/OUTPUT CAN BE ACCURATELY MESURED ON A 'PIECE BY PIECE BASIS', and where the PRODUCTION PROCESS CAN BE DIVIDED UP (E.G F1 Pit-Stop) however there are many jobs where the output of an individual worker can't easily be measured such as teachers, nurses etc...
TASK 1: Find your own animated gif online showing a repetitive work task. Then save it and then upload HERE and add the appropriate text, then save and insert it into your google notebook. Next to it write a paragraph defining TAYLORISM and explain how it could be applied to your picture.
TASK 2: From the following list of jobs say what you could measure to find out how effectively the employees are working (how much output they are producing?)
Car production workers = Number of cars per hour
Shop assistant = ?
Waiter = ?
Teacher = ?
Police officer = ?
Soldier = ?
Baker = ?
Student = ?
TASK 3: Are there any jobs from the list for which output is difficult to measure? If so, explain why it is difficult to measure their output in each case. If you cannot measure workers' output how can you pay them more money if they work harder or more effectively? Does this present problems for modern economies today where the majority of the workforce work in service sector jobs?
ABRAHAM MASLOW studied employee motivation, and he proposed a 'HIERARCHY of NEEDS'. He proposed that if employers wished to motivate their employees they would have to first identify which needs the job already satisfies, then provide ways to allow the employee to benefit from the next level of needs up the hierarchy.
--LIMITATIONS--
Needs are not always easy to categorise and often overlap e.g. more money meets physiological needs but also can also fulfil esteem needs as it can also give status e.g Floyd 'Money' Mayweather.
TASK 1: Create your own hierarchy of needs FOR A STUDENT or for a person/profession of your choice like the Mo Salah example above. Then save it and insert it in your digital notebook.
TASK 2: Copy the text below into your digital notebook an Identify which of Maslow's needs are being satisfied for each of the employees below. Explain the reason for your choices:
Martin works as a farm laborer for a rich landlord. He is a small house on the estate and allowed to grow his own food on a piece of land next to the house. He grows enough food to feed himself and his family and is paid a small wage, which pays for the other needs of the family such as clothes, shoes, and medicines.
Peter works in a car factory on the assembly line. He works in a team of other workers welding the car body together. He is also a member of the company football team. He is well paid and his family can afford quite a few luxuries.
Anna has a degree in business management and professional qualifications in human resource management. She is the human resource manager of a large company. She has her own office with her name on the door and is in charge of the rest of the human resources staff. She works long hours but feels it is worth it if the right employees are recruited to the company.
FREDERICK HERZBERG's motivation theory was based on his study on engineers and accountants in the US. He isolated TWO SETS OF 'NEEDS', the first was 'ANIMAL NEEDS', which he termed 'HYGIENE FACTORS', and 'MOTIVATIONAL NEEDS'.
You will see similarities with Maslow's theory.
'ANIMAL NEEDS', which he termed 'HYGIENE FACTORS', were what workers needed to NOT FEEL DEMOTIVATED, these included
STATUS
SALARY
SECURITY
WORK CONDITIONS
RELATIONSHIPS
For workers to be motivated beyond having their animal needs met, they need to have their 'MOTIVATIONAL NEEDS' met, which included:
ACHIEVEMENT
RECOGNITION
PERSONAL GROWTH
PROMOTION
Copy this past paper into your digital doc and complete.
DOUGLAS MCGREGOR'S research mainly FOCUSED ON THE BELIEF SYSTEMS OF MANAGERS regarding what they perceive motivates their employees.
He identified TWO DISTINCT BELIEF-SYSTEMS that the majority of management fall into with regards their approaches to motivation.
THEORY X managers are those that believe WORKERS ARE NATURALLY LAZY, UNAMBITIOUS and ONLY MOTIVATED BY MONETARY GAIN (Similar to Taylorism) and/or THREATS TO THEIR JOB SECURITY. In other words these type of managers believe they must provide MONETARY INCENTIVES or use JOB SECURITY (Maslow's Physiological and Security needs) to motivate their workers, which usually entails CONSTANT SUPERVISION and possible MICROMANAGING (E.g. CCTV cameras).
In stark contrast, THEORY Y managers are those that believe workers WANT TO DO A GOOD DAYS WORK, are CREATIVE, AMBITIOUS and are motivated by having their higher-order SOCIAL, ESTEEM, and SELF-ACTUALISATION NEEDS met. This level of trust allows managers to DELEGATE MORE RESPONSIBILITY and AVOID MICROMANAGING.
Apply the two belief systems to teachers and how some could be described as Theory Y teachers and other could be described as Theory X teachers in terms of what they think assume motivates students.
-HIGHER WAGES/SALARY
-BONUS (END OF YEAR/CONTRACT)
-PIECE RATE (PER UNIT MADE)
-COMMISSION (PAID % PER SALE)-
-PROFIT-SHARING-
-SHARE OWNERSHIP-
-PERFORMANCE-RELATED-PAY-
JOB ENRICHMENT is a method of motivating employees where a job is designed to have interesting and challenging tasks which can require more skill.
JOB ROTATION is a method of motivating employees where a worker is moved between different tasks in order to 'break up the monotony of doing the same task again and again.
TRAINING can be used as a method of motivating employees as the worker will feel more valued and secure, especially if the company is paying for external off-site training
-TEAMWORKING-
-PROMOTIONAL OPPORTUNITIES-
-COMPANY CAR-
-HOUSING ALLOWANCE-
-PENSION SCHEME-
How can Mr. Bounous motivate you to get an A* and make him look good? Justify your answer (Tip: How could Mr B use a type of job rotation or enrichment to help motivate you?)
"In my opinion, the best way for Mr. Bounous to motivate me to attain an A* in IGCSE Business Studies would be to use a combination of financial and non-financial methods. In terms of a financial method I would suggest,...this is because..., however as a non-financial method I would like some form of...., because...."
--REVISION MATERIALS--
2-MARK: 'State', 'Define', 'Identify two...'
4-MARK: 'Identify and explain two/one advantage and one disadvantage...'
HBN Identify and explain one advantage and one disadvantage to HBN of using job enrichment as one way to motivate its employees.
FILLTUM Identify and explain two ways in which having a well-motivated workforce can help Filltum achieve success.
BILL Identify and explain two reasons why it would be important for Bill to be motivated if he starts his own business.
BUSHALL Identify and explain two possible reasons why ‘Taylor’s theory of motivation might not work’ at Bushall.
GCN Identify and explain two ways in which GCN could use Herzberg’s theory to motivate its employees.
STEPPA Identify and explain two effects on Steppa of a high number of workers leaving the business each year.
TUKAN Identify and explain two advantages to TUKAN of introducing non-financial methods.
SCT Outline two effects of a high rate of labour turnover to SCT.
6-MARK '
KANE Do you think increasing wages is a better way for a business to motivate employees than introducing profit sharing? Justify your answer.
EGT Identify and explain two ways in which the Human Resources manager of EGT could use her knowledge of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs to motivate employees.
VXH Do you think VXH should use job rotation or financial bonuses to increase employee motivation? Justify your answer.
BEN Explain two ways Ben could improve employee motivation. Recommend which way Ben should choose. Justify your answer.
A2Z Do you think that using financial rewards is the best way for A2Z to motivate its pilots? Justify your answer.
TWH Identify and explain two ways that TWH could improve the motivation of its employees.
8-MARK
Case study link (RR) Identify and explain two possible reasons why Richard needs a well-motivated workforce.
Casr study link (TT) Identify two motivational theories and explain how TT could use these theories to help increase worker motivation
Case study link (P&P) P & P needs to be efficient. Identify and explain four methods P & P could use to motivate production workers.
Case study link (RRM) Rafael’s son wants to know more about motivating employees. Identify and explain four levels of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs as they might apply to Rafael’s employees.
12-MARKS
Case study link. (ES) Consider three methods of motivation ES could use for its production workers. Which is the
Case study link (SA) Consider the following three benefits to SA of having well-motivated employees (Higher output, Fewer employees leaving, Higher quality). Which benefit will be the most important to SA if it wants to increase profit? Justify your answer.
Case study link (WA) Consider the following three ways WA could use to increase employee motivation. Recommend which way WA should choose. Justify your answer.
Case study link (AH) Consider the advantages of working for AH and the advantages of working for BB Heating. Recommend whether AH employees should apply to work for BB Heating. Justify your answer.